[July 8, 1967] Family lines (August 1967 Galaxy)


by Gideon Marcus

Royal Families

The news always likes to focus on heads of state, especially when they are flashy or glamorous in some way.  From Princess Grace of Monaco to Crown Prince Akihito of Japan, these leaders are instant idols, somehow more compelling for having the reins (and reigns) of nations even though they presumably put their pants/skirts/obis on the same way as the common folk.

This week scored a triplet of spotlights.  For instance, in the island nation of Tonga, Taufaʻahau Tupou IV was crowned monarch in a ceremony that included a feast of 71,000 suckling pigs!  And that, by itself, tells you all you need to know about the current Jewish/Moslem population of Tonga…

Closer to home, El BJ, chief of the United States, has got his first grandson.  Patrick Lyndon Nugent is the newborn child of First Daughter Luci Nugent (neé Johnson).  There is no word, as yet, whether his toddler status will grant him deferment in the lastest draft lottery.

Finally, junta chairman General Nguyen Cao Ky, the flamboyant leader of South Vietnam since 1965, has decided not to run for President in the upcoming democratic (perhaps) September elections.  Premier Thiệu has been backed by the junta for the top role, instead, with Ky getting the Vice Presidential nod.  It's all a lot of musical chairs, anyway. After all, Ky has asserted that the only politician he admires is Hitler, which tells you all you need to know about the state of democracy in that country (and its current Jewish population…)

Watching Big Brother

Fred Pohl, one of the original Futurians and a pillar of the SF community, has had his hands full for nearly a decade.  After he took over the reins of Galaxy and the newly acquired IF from H. L. Gold, rather than sit on his laurels, he looked for new worlds to conquer.  Thus, Worlds of Tomorrow was launched in 1963.  But juggling three mags (plus a few reprint-only titles) was a challenging job, often resulting in uneven quality and occasionally right-out flubs.  For instance, last year's issue of Worlds of Tomorrow where the pages got all mixed up.

One would think, with WoT going out of publication, that things might be less hectic over at the Guinn Co. mags.  But, in fact, this month's issue of Galaxy is even more higgledy-piggledy, making reading a real challenge.


by Sol Dember

Which is a shame, because there's some quite good stuff in here (mixed with some mediocre stuff, to be sure).  Thankfully, you've got me to be your guide.  Just grab your compass, or you might get lost.

Hawksbill Station, by Robert Silverberg


by Virgil Finlay

One-way time travel is developed in the early 21st Century.  Since humanity is deathly afraid of creating paradoxes, the new portals are used by the totalitarian regime for just one purpose: shipping undesirables into the far past, a sort of Paleozoic Botany Bay.

Hawksbill Station is the one reserved for male subversives, established sometime in the late Cambrian (Silverberg repeatedly gives a date of two billion years ago, but of course, the Cambrian went from about 600-500 million B.C.) Our perspective is that of Barrett, the de facto head of the more than 100 settler/prisoners on the coast of what will one day be the Atlantic Ocean.  It is a community slowly decaying as its denizens age along with no greater purpose in life.  That is, until a new young convict arrives from the future, one who appears to be a government spy…

This is more of a travelogue than a story, and the ending comes on a bit abruptly.  But the characterization, the details, the setting are all so gripping that I tore through the novella in no time, despite the labyrinthine page distribution.

Four stars, and if it ever gets expanded into a novel, it could make five.

Angel, Dark Angel, by Roger Zelazny

In another future-set tale, society is maintained by a sort of corporate Angel of Death who, with the help of ten thousand teleporting assistants, brings death to citizens after they have made sufficient contribution to humanity (and are, perhaps, on the verge of being detrimental).

One noteworthy woman has cultivated the aesthetic race of spirules (depicted on the cover) as an antidote to the cold, mechanistic technology of her time.  A subordinate angel is sent to dispatch her, but things prove more complicated.

This is a middlin' Zelazny story, not an empty poetic suit like some, but not a near masterpiece like some of his other works.  Three stars.

We're Coming Through the Window, by K. M. O'donnell

Throwaway vignette about a fellow who keeps duplicating himself due to time travel and needs Fred Pohl's help to get out of it.

Cute.  Three stars.

Ginny Wrapped in the Sun, by R. A. Lafferty

Ginny seems to be a precocious four year old, but in fact, is actually just a baseline human, maturing at age 4 and going on as an upright monkey.  It's the rest of us who are evolutionary aberrations, having five times as many heartbeats that a creature our mass should have.  Inevitably, Lafferty suggests, we'll all go ape.

This tale doesn't really work, and it's a bit more impenetrable than Lafferty's usual fare.  Two stars.

For Your Information: A Pangolin Is a Pangolin, by Willy Ley

Ley's article on the strange mammal that is neither aardvark nor anteater nor armadillo is interesting, but not much more than you might get from a rather good encyclopedia entry.

Three stars.

9-9-99, by Richard Wilson

Two wizened old characters are determined to settle an old score since both have outlived their wagered death dates, the bet having been made back in the 30s.

Whether it is even possible for them to collect given the state of the Earth in the late '90s is another matter…

Good enough, I guess.  Three stars.


by Wally Wood

Travelers Guide to Megahouston, by H. H. Hollis


by Wally Wood

This is a very long, somewhat farcical account of a 21st Century evolution of the Astrodome, in which domes enclose whole cities.

Pretty dull stuff.  Two stars.

The Being in the Tank, by Theodore L. Thomas

An alien being materializes in the heart of a hellish hydrazine factory and demands to speak to the President.  But is he the real deal?

Forgettable, but inoffensive.  A low three stars.

Hide and Seek, by Linda Marlowe

A childhood game is adapted into a method of population control.  It has shock value, but little else.

Two stars.

The Great Stupids, by Miriam Allen deFord

Mad scientist makes everyone under 50 a mental moron, all in service of a rather lame joke at the end.  DeFord was once one of the stars of the genre, but her light has waned over the years.  Here's hoping she's a Cepheid variable and not a dying dwarf.

To Outlive Eternity (Part 2 of 2), by Poul Anderson


by Jack Gaughan

It is fitting that the final long piece of the issue is a sort of mirror image of Silverberg's novella in terms of strengths and weaknesses.  As we read in last month's installment, the ramscoop colony ship Leonora Christine suffered damage to its decelerators while traveling at near light speed on the way to Beta Virginis.  The solution: to accelerate to terrific velocities instead, plunging through the heart of the galaxy and out into the comparative emptiness of intergalactic space where repairs might be effected.

In this half, event after event conspires to force the Christine to travel ever faster and faster, ultimately spanning the lifespan of the universe and beyond in a matter of months.  The story is told as a series of problem-solving conversations spread out over the weeks, and each character largely exists solely to have these conversations.  Except for the women, of course, who are almost universally hysterics or hangers-on…except for the First Officer who ultimately whores herself out for the good of the crew.

In short, the setup and ideas are really neat, but its a plot outline, not a novel.  And where Poul Anderson does try to characterize, it's with quick stereotypes, and usually not agreeable ones.  As for setting, there really isn't one.  The crew of the Christine might as well be floating heads in blank spaces for all we really get to experience the ship.

Readable, but badly flawed.  Three stars.

Matrix Goose, by Jack Sharkey

Last up, some very familiar nursery rhymes as they might be rendered by robots–after the demise of humanity.  It's cute.  Three stars.


Perhaps my favorite example, art by Gray Morrow

Cross-eyed Kin

And so, Galaxy ends up a largely enjoyable, but unremarkable read — just under 3 stars in ranking.  Perhaps, with the demise of Worlds of Tomorrow further in the rear-view mirror, Pohl will be able to concentrate on (and concentrate the best stories into) his remaining mags.

On the other hand, perhaps he hasn't learned his lesson.  He's got a new magazine is coming out next month…





8 thoughts on “[July 8, 1967] Family lines (August 1967 Galaxy)”

  1. H. H. Hollis was a pseudonym of Ben Neal Ramey , a fellow Houstonian. He belonged to the fan group here in the 1960s. His day job was as an attorney. A clever and funny man I wish we had of seen more of him.
    I agree about the story rating but then Ramey probably would have too, writing was like for many just a hobby.
    We talked about that story because it was wish full thinking , trying to figure out house to fix Houston's god awful heat index problem !

  2. "Hawksbill Station" is very, very good. I'm willing to overlook the paleontology mistake (I did also wonder if there would be enough oxygen in the atmosphere to make it breathable without any sort of land-based plant life), because the characters are what matter and they're largely well done. If Silverberg does expand the story, it will probably improve it, but I don't know if he needs to.

    You liked the Zelazny better than I thought you would. To me it seemed the mode in which you like him least. I wasn't particularly taken with it either. He can do a lot better.

    The O'Donnell story was all right. Fred may be a bit susceptible to epistolary stories that involve him. There was that one about the fan club in IF a few months ago. It's an older concept that got used a lot in the pulp days, but we should have moved beyond it by now.

    I didn't like the Lafferty. I've come to the conclusion that he's at his weakest when he tries to tell a story with a largely traditional structure, even if it does include his unique whimsy. This was basically Lafferty writes Bradbury… badly.

    The pangolin article was all right, though awfully superficial. Asimov would have turned this into an article about how zoologists decide what animals are related to each other. I did like the bit about the museum removing all the signage from their pangolin and asking visitors what they thought it was.

    "9-9-99" was decent filler. I'd already forgotten it when I read your review and I'm sure I'll have forgotten it again in a couple of days.

    "Megahouston" was dreadfully dull. And here, I'd thought Hollis was improving as an author.

    The Thomas was another OK, but nothing more story. It is nice to be reminded occasionally that he can write. I just wish he'd try harder.

    "Hide and Seek" is another attempt at Bradbury. Two fairly unsuccessful attempts in one magazine is too many.

    It's been quite a while since Mrs. deFord wrote something I really liked. It's too bad, since she was once very good. That's two stories by women in one issue, which is good, but they're both subpar, which is bad.

    I liked the Anderson more than you did. It would definitely be improved by being fleshed out, but it's probably 50-50 if Poul is the person to do it. If he digs into the characters, great, but he could easily just give us more of the same.

    And I didn't really care for the Sharkey poems. But then, I don't much care for poetry in general.

    1. Regarding Hawksbill, I asked Bob about the age discrepancy — he said he has a private theory that our current estimates of the geologic timescale are all wrong.

      As for oxygen, I should think oxygenating plants in the ocean (which produce 70% of our oxygen today) would be sufficient to make a breathable atmosphere.

  3. The Silverberg is definitely the highlight of the issue.  He's really maturing as a writer.

    The Anderson has some nice Sense of Wonder to the premise, and is probably the second beat thing in the issue.

  4. I see Asimov is taking over the editorial to also be angry at the New Wave. Apparently not just bad writing, also going to cause the decline and fall of civilization. Good to know these old guards responses continue to be considered and proportional!

    I actually rather enjoyed Hawksbill Station. I know, me, enjoying a Silverberg story. Who would have thought it!

    I also feel Angel, Dark Angel was lesser Zelazny. I am not even sure what it is meant to be about and felt unfinished and rushed to me.

    The O'Donnell vignette was enjoyable little piece. Not much to it but vivid and stylistically sound.

    I don't like Lafferty at the best of times and this is definitely not his best. Confusing and unpleasant.

    9-9_99 is an interesting little story, if not extraordinary. Curious about the letter format but guessing the result of the characters' age?

    "Megahouston" is just boring.

    "The Being in the Tank" and "Hide and Seek" are forgettable

    Great Stupids was really really bad. The worst piece in the issue.

    I liked To Outlive Eternity much less than everyone else. I found flat, unpleasant, cliched and (to be quite frank) silly! I felt in this half like I was reading a lesser version of James Blish's Triumph of Time. And when I think a Blish work is better you know I didn't like something!

    It was a surprise to see Sharkey at the end. He seems to have largely left the SF scene (not that I missed him).  This is actually better than his usual stuff. I liked how it started as frivolous jokes and then went on to revealing it is a story of Earth after humans have left.

    So overall, not a huge amount of good stuff in there. Depressingly still better than Galaxy has been in general recently. Not sure if having the old hands come back next issue is the best idea, but we will see.

    Also, there were a lot vignettes in this issue between the two main features. Do we think Pohl needed to fill a lot of space this time around? Maybe a summer burn off before the fall pick up?

  5. Did Silverberg come under the influence, in developing the conception of "Hawksbill Station," of a Twilight Zone teleplay broadcast four years ago, called "On Thursday We Leave for Home"?  The story there was about an isolated colony of Earth people on a distant desert planet, who had failed to make a good go of it, but had kept trying thanks to the encouragement and leadership of one strong man, William Benteen.  When the rescue of the colonists becomes possible, Benteen found it so hard to let go that he stayed behind.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *