[January 30, 1962] Heads or Tails? (Ace Double F-127)

by Gideon Marcus

What if the South had won at Antietam?  Or the Mongols had not been so savaged by the Hungarians at Mohi?  If Hitler had grown up an artist?  Time travel has been a staple of science fiction since the genre was formalized.  One of the newer flavors of the time travel oeuvre is the “sideways-in-time” story, where the “what-if” has become reality.  Sometimes the tale is told in isolation, the characters unaware of any other history.  Oftimes, the alternate timeline is just one of many.

Keith Laumer published one of the latter type in the pages of last year’s Fantastic, an engaging yarn called Worlds of the Imperium.  In this serial, Brion Bayard, a minor diplomat dispatched to Stockholm, is abducted by agents from another Earth.  The world he is brought to is under the benign domination of an Anglo-German empire, one whose technology and culture are somewhat mired in the Victorian age, but with one critical difference: The Imperium has perfected the Maxoni-Cocini engine that facilitates cross-timeline travel.

The M-C drive is a finicky thing.  One slight error in construction results not only in the destruction of the vehicle, but the entire planet.  In fact, the Imperium’s timeline is surrounded to a vast distance by blighted worlds where development of the M-C drive resulted in catastrophe.  Only two exceptions exist – our Earth (“Blight Insular Three”), and a closely related world (“Blight Insular Two”) that avoided M-C destruction but fell prey to atomic apocalypse.  This latter world has begun to raid the Imperium timeline with increasing effectiveness; it is only a matter of time until they succeed in its conquest.  Bayard is the key to the Imperium’s survival.

I won’t tell you how he is the key, nor anything else about the plot of this fun book, just published as one half of Ace Double F-127.  It reads a bit like one of Laumer’s Retief novels without the comedy.  I like any story that features a hero who is my age (42), and it is one of the few books that accurately portrays the debilitating aftereffects of being truly worked over in a fight.  On the negative side of the ledger, Imperium is a bit too short and a touch too glib; while the adventure is exciting and the histories intriguing, somehow, the work fails to leave a much impact.  Also, the female lead, the intrepid Swede Barbro, is as undeveloped as a pencil sketch, which makes the ensuing romance between her and Bayard feel tacked on. 

Still, I do love alternate history, and Imperium is decent (if not stellar) Laumer.  Three and a half stars.

Now, flip over F-127, and what do we have?  Seven from the Stars, the brand new second novel by Marion Zimmer Bradley (she gave us The Door through Space last year.)

In Stars, a handful of alien colonists survive a spaceship malfunction on the edge of known (to them) space.  Refugees from a telepathic society (the Dvaneth), three of them are psi-endowed. The planet on which the seven have crashed is not immediately identified, but it becomes quickly apparent that the world is Earth. 

This is something of a mixed blessing: Earth is hospitable to the Dvaneth, who are human in every way (this extreme coincidence is never explained.) Moreover, the telempathic castaway called Mathis is able to learn and convey the languages of the Texan natives to the refugees.  Since the colonists look Hispanic, fitting in does not prove difficult.  There is even a Dvaneth citizen already installed on Earth, a Watcher who reports on planetary affairs from behind the shield of a terran cover identity.  If the colonists can find him, they are halfway to safety.

There is a downside, however.  The incorporeal parasite beings, the Rhu-inn, the bane of Dvaneth existence, are endemic to Earth’s sector of space.  Having no bodies of their own, they inhabit those of hapless humans, forcing them to to their bidding.  Until a planetary shield can be erected against the Rhu-inn, Earth cannot be visited by Dvaneth vessels, and the castaways have no chance of rescue.  Worse still, it quickly becomes apparent that a Rhu-inn has already infested at least one human, and planetary conquest is imminent.  Can the invader be stopped in time?

All in all, not a bad set up, if a bit hoary.  Where the book falls down is execution.  Bradley is a new writer, and it shows, with all emotions and dialogue dripping with melodrama – the book equivalent of the comic strips’ inability to use any punctuation but the exclamation mark.  As in Imperium, the romance subplots are perfunctory and hackneyed. 

Most disturbing is the constant undercurrent of violence.  I’m not certain if this was a stylistic choice on Bradley’s part, a way of distinguishing the Dvaneth culture, but if people aren’t striking each other, or contemplating striking each other, they are shouting.  Bradley’s castaways are constantly at the edge of a rage, their knuckles white in clenched fists.  Only the albino empath, Dionie, seems to rise above base emotions – and Bradley makes her the victim of a near rape!  I suppose this kind of roughness is tolerable (expected?) in a Howard-esque fantasy (a la Door through Space) but in Stars, I found it off-putting.  Two stars.

Should you pick up F-127?  While it is the least of the Ace Doubles I’ve yet picked up, I think the Laumer makes it a worthy purchase, particularly at just 40 cents.  And you may like Stats better than I did.

Coming up…January’s exciting Space Race developments!

[By the way, I have been advised that Galactic Journey qualifies for “Best Fanzine” rather than “Best Related Work.”  If you were planning on nominating the Journey for a Hugo, we would greatly appreciate your changing your vote accordingly.  Thank you!]

10 thoughts on “[January 30, 1962] Heads or Tails? (Ace Double F-127)”

  1. When I read “Imperium” in Fantastic it knocked my socks off. The sort of thing that could happen to anybody–if they’re lucky.  What I didn’t like about the ACE edition was that it was slightly abridged; passages and descriptions that added “texture” were deleted, so I was disappointed.  On the other hand, the 1965 sequel, “The Other Side Of Time” when published by Berkeley Books, was expanded from its appearance in Fantastic, so that was grand. // “Seven from the Stars” was also great.  In fact, I and a friend in the business tried to option it for a film, but her agents wanted a big-budget film, which was crazy because we could’ve filmed it in the Santa Clara Valley with minimal SPFX.  (The same friend and I took out a 2-year option on Jack Williamson’s “Dome Around America.” We couldn’t get the funding, which was sad because Williamson called my script the best adaptation of his work that he’d ever seen.) :(

  2. The first three novels were reissued by Baen in 2012 as an omnibus called “Imperium.”  It has the restored text of the original magazine appearance of WOTI.

  3. The Laumer is a great read, space opera and Ruritanian at the same time. And I love that A-entropy action. I agree about Barbro, but at least Laumer seems to realise his weakness, and doesn’t spnd much paper on her.

    (Bradley is one of those authors who don’t click for me.)

  4. In 1958 the Dallas Futurians held the first reginal science fiction convention in Texas at the Dallas Hotel. Wilson Tucker had been invited as guest of honor, but could not make it. Tom Reamy, who ran the convention, knew Marion Zimmer Bradley who had just published a few SF stories. At that time she was living in Andrews Texas , about as bleak West Texas as one can get! She was 28 and a lively conversationalist. I bought the carbon copy of her Seven to the Stars in 1960 for 11 dollars, and am keeping it to sell later, I hope it fetches something

  5. SEVEN FROM THE STARS isn’t (quite) a “new” 1961 novel; it appeared as the lead “novel” in the March 1960 AMAZING.  (I’m not sure if the Ace version is revised/longer/shorter, though.)

    And Bradley isn’t really a “new” writer either: her first professional publication came way back in 1953, with two stories in the admittedly minor magazine VORTEX.  Also, she’s been a prolific writer for and publisher of fanzines, and a frequently publsihed pulp letterhack, since at least 1947.

    I think I liked SEVEN FROM THE STARS a bit more than you did, but I agree that THE DOOR THROUGH SPACE was more fun.

  6. I enjoyed the Laumer a lot when it ran in Fantastic. It does have that whiz-bang pacing of the Retief stories, doesn’t it? Actually, a bit of humor might have improved the story a little. This story also caused me to get confused when Analog serialized “A Sense of Obligation”. I kept confusing Harrison’s Brion Brandd with Laumer’s Brion Bayard from a few months earlier.

    Can one really say that the subgenre of alternate timelines is all that new? Murray Leinster wrote “Sidewise in Time” in 1934! That makes the concept older than at least two of your regular contributors and probably some of your readers as well.

    I doubt I’ll go looking for the Bradley. She doesn’t really work for me, either. I’ll read her stuff when it shows up in the magazines, but I don’t really feel an urge to seek her out especially. And part of that, I think, may be that undercurrent of violence you mention. It seems to me we’ve seen that in some of her previous work.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.