[January 20, 1966] Bombs, duds, and happy endings (February 1966 Fantasy and Science Fiction)


by Gideon Marcus

Near miss

Three days ago, a B-52 nuclear bomber crashed into a KC-135 tanker aircraft off the southern coast of Spain.  The tanker was immediately destroyed, killing its four crew, and the B-52 crashed — four of its seven crew survived.

The payload of said bomber had a similarly mixed fate: two of the bombs exploded upon hitting the ground, though the nuclear device did not activate.  As a result, there is now an irradiated zone near the fishing village of Palomares.  The third bomb did not go off at all.

A fourth bomb fell into the Mediterranean Sea.  We're still looking for that one; with luck, it will be found and all will be fine.  I can't imagine Franco will want us flying our bombers over Spanish airspace anymore, though.

Turbulent flying

While The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction has not plumbed the same depths it often did under the brief editorship of Avram Davidson, nevertheless Joe Ferman's F&SF has almost as many ups and downs as a Japan-bound 707 crossing a jet stream boundary.  After last month's lousy outing (which followed the previous month's excellent issue), we're on something of a level flight path.  The stories in this month's issue range from fair to middlin' with only one stand-out and one definite clunker.


by George Salter

The Gadge System, by Reginald Bretnor

Assembly line schmo, Joe Gadge, decides to quit his job and light for Burma.  His goal: to secure the inset ruby of an idol whereby to become a millionaire and win the hand of his sweetheart.  Thus ensues an amusing send-up of the typical pulp jungle adventure.  I particularly appreciated the subversion of racist clichés.

Bretnor has mostly stayed away from the SFF scene, having devoted his energies instead to the monthly pun columns that used to curse…er…grace F&SF.  This latest piece feels like a relic of the last decade, but it's pleasant reading.

Three stars.


by Gahan Wilson

Against Authority, by Miriam Allen deFord

Two young men and an extraordinary young woman are poised to rid New Turkey of "Authority", the long-installed dictator who sprang to power in the wake of a devastating alien invasion.  But the revolt is subverted even as it starts, and the plot appears to be some kind of grooming by Authority himself to find talented agents.

Where one wheel exists within another, one can be certain a third ring remains to be discovered as well.

While this story is an enjoyable pageturner, the plot is archaic (no surprise — deFord is one of the genre's longest serving veterans) and it all ends too abruptly for satisfaction.

If the previous story scraped the line between three and four stars, Against Authority hovers just above this ranking's lower boundary.

An Afternoon in May, by Richard Winkler

A library is under siege, its elderly operators determined to turn its shelves into a literary Alamo against the ignorant mob of would-be book burners.  May covers the same ground as Bradbury's The Fireman, though with a lighter touch ("The situation is hopeless, but not serious.")

Three stars.

Witness for the Persecution, by Randall Garrett

On a far off human planet in a binary system, Walt Gayle finds himself the target of a vigorous assassination plot after purchasing the secret of artificial gravity from the Interstellar Traders.  He is only saved by the ministrations of one Jeremiah, who seems to be almost omnipotent.  Why is Gayle hunted, and what lies at the other end of the chase?

I'm not sure why this story didn't get sold to Analog, where it would seem more at home.  I do know that F&SF has been trying to get more space stories of late (to maintain the "SF" part of its name).

Anyway, it's not bad, but it's also nothing you haven't seen before, and you likely won't remember it next month.  Certainly, the "surprise" reveal at the end is anything but.

Three stars.

Desynchronosis, by Theodore L. Thomas

There is a new malady that afflicts those of us in the Jet Set: "time zone syndrome".  In this article, surprisingly bereft of the Thomas' half-baked SF story seeds, the author posits that there may be other cycles beyond the 24-hour one that rule our biology.

Three stars.  I wish it had been a full length article.

The New Men, by Joanna Russ

In 1986, a East Bloc dignitary stranded in Poland by a broken down car seeks shelter in an ancient bougeois fortress.  Its resident appears to be a 400 year old Count, dusty but well-preserved.  Literate (if obtuse and veiled) horror ensues.

Russ is very good at aping older styles of writing, and she has produced some near masterpieces in the process.  This latest story will not be one of them, I'm afraid.  Perhaps I'm not versed enough in the legend it's modernizing.

Three stars.

The Way Back, by D. K. Findlay

Often, a science fiction story will be spawned by the latest scientific discovery.  In The Way Back's case, it's the recent revelation that the universe not only was created in a Big Bang, but that it may eventually collapse under its own gravitation back into a gravitational point source. 

This rather incoherent piece suggests that the process of collapse will begin in the next few decades (it won't) and that accompanying the collapse will be a gradual de-evolution of humanity (what?!)

Two stars.

Up and Down the Earth, by Isaac Asimov

The Good Doctor takes up the subject of mountains, describing the highest heights by continent, and also under various other circumstances: distance of peaks from the Earth's core, height of mountains if the oceans were drained, etc.  Missing is the most important statistic, of course: length of ascent from base to summit.

Another geographical dart throw.  Three stars.

The Mountains of Magnatz, by Jack Vance

Speaking of mountains…

Despite the punnish name, there is no relation between this story and Lovecraft's swansong, In the Mountains of Madness.  Instead, we have the sequel to the first story of Cugel the Clever, a charlatan tasked by a sorcerer to find and return an ancient magical relic.  Cugel navigates whirlpools, deodands, and trecherous townsfolk in an adventure that is half Howard, half Baum.

A little too trivial to be sublime, it is nevertheless quite clever and a lot of fun.

Four stars.

Girls Will Be Girls, by Doris Pitkin Buck

Last up as sort of a postlude is a cautionary tale about telepathy.  A young esper woman is weary of her access to the primitive and lewed thoughts of the men around her — but she's even more horrified when the thoughts of an intended beaux do not incline toward the crude.

At least, I think that's the point of this story.

Three stars.

Cruising Altitude

And so we make it through another month of F&SF, this time without any untoward accidents, but also without many memorable incidents.  At some point, I expect the Vance will be fixed up into a book, and there won't be much reason to return to this issue.

I suppose tolerable mediocrity is better than significant dross.  We're due for a really good issue, though, I hope we get one next month!






5 thoughts on “[January 20, 1966] Bombs, duds, and happy endings (February 1966 Fantasy and Science Fiction)”

  1. I have fond memories of those pulpy old jungle adventures, though I'm sure I'd look askance at much that is in them these days. Bretnor actually does a fine job of tweaking their nose for what was wrong with them while still celebrating the bits that were good.

    I've noted before that Mrs. deFord has been off her game of late. While not great, it's better than most of what we've seen from her for a while now. And points to her for an active female character who isn't just along for the ride/a reward for the hero. The Turkish setting was also unusual and interesting.

    "An Afternoon in May" is a fine little tale that might have gone unnoticed in a stronger issue. On the other hand, if it had been in last month's issue it would have shone like a diamond in the gutter.

    "Witness" got off to a decent start and then wandered around aimlessly. Middle-of-the-road Garrett. Maybe my biggest problem with it is that I was expecting a Lord Darcy story from the title. My disappointment may have colored my view.

    Even if this article is better than most, I'm still ready to dump Thomas' "Science Springboard". There have been studies where people are isolated from time cues and they seem to have a natural cycle closer to 25 hours than 24. That might play a role on the Moon where the length of the "day" is irrelevant and make living on Mars more comfortable.

    I find it hard to believe you're not well-versed in the legend Russ is playing with in "The New Men". Perhaps you'd have recognized it better if it had been set in the eastern Balkans. Or maybe it's a lack of familiarity with Polish cuisine and its use of a certain member of the Allium family.

    "The Way Back" was awful. Even if you accept its ridiculous premise, why would millions of years of evolution leap backwards in a generation?

    Another article on superlatives from Asimov. I'm tired of them, though this one was better than some. Give us some chemistry or physics, Dr. A. Please.

    I missed the reference in the title of the Vance story. (By the way, it's "At the Mountains of Madness" not "In" and was hardly Lovecraft's swansong, having been written in 1931 and coming out a year before his death, being followed by several more stories before his passing.) In any case, Vance has given us a fun tale. I suspect that Cugel's byname is probably ironic.

    I'm not sure of the point of the Buck story either. Not terrible, but a story that will be quickly forgotten.

  2. "I find it hard to believe you’re not well-versed in the legend Russ is playing with in “The New Men”. Perhaps you’d have recognized it better if it had been set in the eastern Balkans. Or maybe it’s a lack of familiarity with Polish cuisine and its use of a certain member of the Allium family."

    I only look omniscient…

    "I missed the reference in the title of the Vance story. (By the way, it’s “At the Mountains of Madness” not “In” and was hardly Lovecraft’s swansong, having been written in 1931 and coming out a year before his death, being followed by several more stories before his passing.) In any case, Vance has given us a fun tale. I suspect that Cugel’s byname is probably ironic."

    I used the term swansong advisedly. I know it's not his last story, but it's by far my favorite! And it's close to the end and his most interesting.

  3. DemetriosX wrote: '“The Way Back” … even if you accept its ridiculous premise, why would millions of years of evolution leap backwards in a generation?'

    Heh. If you did accept its ridiculous premise, why _not_ accept that millions of years of evolution can leap backwards in a generation, too?

    One is thankful for the Vance, at any rate.

  4. Yes, not a memorable issue.  Maybe the most interesting thing is a cover by George Salter, whose unique style appeared on the magazine in its early days, but who hasn't done one for more than a decade.

    The Vance series is starting to look like one long sword-and-sorcery shaggy dog story.

  5. I was never a fan of the Jungle stories and so the Gadge System didn't really do much for me I am afraid.

    deFord does seem to struggle with longer pieces of late. Not terrible all felt a little well trodden.

    Afternoon in May was again okay, but given how few venues there now are for original science fiction I always find it disappointing when magazine pages are used for reprints nowadays.

    Garrett continues to be totally opaque to me.

    On the other hand I very much enjoyed the Russ story, fun to see the clash between old legends and communism.

    The Way Back was indeed awful.

    The Cugel story I don't think was as good as the last one, but still enjoyable.

    And yes the final piece is reasonable but forgettable.

    So overall, not much to recommend this month's issue for me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *