[January 22, 1964] The British Are Coming!  The Americans Are Here! (February 1964 Fantastic)


by Victoria Silverwolf

Galactic Journeyers from the United Kingdom have often spoken about the strange phenomenon known as Beatlemania.  Not too long ago, CBS News offered a report on the craze.

This peculiar form of passionate devotion to four shaggy-haired musicians has made little impact here in the United States.  That may change soon.


released January 10


released January 20

With the nearly simultaneous release of Beatles albums by two rival record companies this month, Yanks have the opportunity to judge the British quartet for themselves.

For now, Americans seem to prefer ballads to upbeat rock 'n' roll.

Originally a hit for baritone Vaughn Monroe nearly twenty years ago, crooner Bobby Vinton reached the top of the charts for the third time with his sentimental remake.

Whether or not the USA welcomes the foursome from Britain remains to be seen.  It might be an omen that the latest issue of Fantastic features only American authors. 

Novelty Act, by Philip K. Dick

This prolific author specializes in quirky accounts of tomorrow's fads and follies.  His latest offering is no exception.

Most Americans live in gigantic communal apartment buildings.  The government still allows voting, but there's only one political party.  The President has no real power.  The most revered figure is the First Lady, who is still young and beautiful after a century.

(The description of the character, and the way in which the nation idolizes her, suggest that she is a parody of Jacqueline Kennedy.  The writer could not predict that the target of his gentle mocking would soon suffer a devastating tragedy.)

The protagonist dreams of winning the First Lady's favor by performing classical music with his brother on water jugs.  The brother works at a spaceship dealer, with the help of a robotic imitation of an extinct Martian creature.  The device, like the defunct Martians, can influence human minds.  Everything comes together when the brothers make their appearance before the First Lady, and discover her secret.

This is a mixture of comedy and serious political satire.  Imaginative details create a portrait of a neurotic future United States.  A hint at the end that the brothers may escape their subtle dystopia lighten the story's mood.  Although the plot is disjointed at times, it makes satisfying reading.

Four stars.

The Soft Woman, by Theodore L. Thomas

A man has a doll that looks like a naked woman with the head of a frog.  He meets a beautiful woman and brings her to his room.  A strange and frightening thing happens to him.

I can't say much more about this very brief story without giving away the ending.  It confused me.  I don't understand why the doll has a frog's head, or why it's named maMal [sic].  There seems no good reason for the man's unfortunate fate.  There's some beautiful writing, but what does it all mean?

Two stars.

The Orginorg Way, by Jack Sharkey

An unattractive fellow who grew up alone in a Brazilian jungle has a strange ability to crossbreed plants into organic versions of technological devices.  At first, he makes simple things like fishing rods.  Eventually he creates substitutes for telephones and lightbulbs.  He earns a vast fortune, enabling him to win the girl of his dreams.  Of course, there's an ironic ending.

The absurd misadventures of the protagonist provide mild amusement.  They way in which the plants imitate machines shows some imagination.  As a whole, however, the story is too silly.

Two stars.

The Lords of Quarmall (Part Two of Two), by Fritz Leiber and Harry Fischer

The conclusion of this short novel brings Fafhrd and the Gray Mouser together, along with the two rival brothers they serve, at the funeral pyre of the siblings' father.  The death of the ruler of the underground kingdom leads to open warfare between his heirs.  Sorcery and swordplay follow.

Disguise, deception, and skulking around keep the story moving at a rapid pace.  A major twist in the plot near the end is predictable.  Although there's plenty of colorful adventure, much of the hugger-mugger seems arbitrary.

Three stars.

They Never Come Back From Whoosh!, by David R. Bunch

In this surreal tale, people go inside a gigantic, soot-spewing building.  They do not return.  The narrator, like the others, feels a compulsion to enter the place, against his own will.  Within he meets one of the building's strange caretakers.

This is a bizarre allegory of life, death, nature, and technology.  The author's unique style is compelling, if not always lucid.

Three stars.

Return to Brobdingnag, by Adam Bradford, M.D.

A couple of months ago, the fictional Doctor Bradford journeyed to Lilliput, Jonathan Swift's land of tiny people.  Now he visits the realm of giants.  He finds out that they keep their population under control through death control instead of birth control.  Whenever a baby is born, an elderly person takes poison to ensure a quick and painless demise.  Their government is democratic, but the elite have more votes per person than the lower classes.  The author also describes the science-based sun worship of the inhabitants, as well as their unusual way of performing surgery.

As with the previous installment in this series, the story takes far too long to get the narrator to his destination.  The peculiar ways of the Brobdingnagians seem arbitrary, with no satiric point.

One star.

Death Before Dishonor, by Dobbin Thorpe

As we saw last month, Dobbin Thorpe is really Thomas M. Disch in disguise.  Like Thorpe's creation in the previous issue, this is a tale of horror.

A woman wakes up from an alcoholic blackout and finds a tattoo on her thigh.  She has no memory of how she got it.  It turns out she had a one-night affair with a tattoo artist while she was drunk.  The tattooist is a man of uncommon skill.  His creations have a life of their own.  The woman's romance with another man leads to terrifying consequences.

The story is gruesome, with a touch of very dark humor.  Some might see it as a cautionary tale about drunkenness and promiscuity.  I think the author just came up with a scary idea, and the plot grew out of it.  On that level, it works well enough.

Three stars.

Summing Up

With eight Americans offering seven works of imagination, there are certain to be some stories you like and some you don't.  I appreciate the wide range of fiction found here.  We have satire, pastiche, adventure, allegory, comedy, surrealism, and horror.  The only thing I'd like to stir into the mixture would be a few pieces from talented British writers.  A story by Aldiss, Ballard, or Clarke – to mention just the ABC's of the UK – would be refreshing.  Maybe the Beatles will add the same thing to American popular music.  At least it would mix things up a bit.

(Did you read about all the ways the Journey expanded last year?  Catch up and see what you missed!)




4 thoughts on “[January 22, 1964] The British Are Coming!  The Americans Are Here! (February 1964 Fantastic)”

  1. Those Beatles sound like they have good heads on their shoulders and haven't gotten all caught up in the hype about them and their music. Good for them. It's rare to see that much sense in people who have such success at a young age.

    As for this month's issue of Fantastic, I was rather less impressed. Indeed, I felt there was a rather strong thread of misogyny running through it, but maybe that was just me.

    Phil Dick has been cranking out stories of late. "Novelty Act" was certainly one of the better that we've seen. It may have been somewhat over long, but that may just be me. I continue to not really care much for his work, although I haven't quite got to the point our host is with Ray Bradbury.

    "The Soft Woman" was the first story that I felt had some anti-woman sentiment in it. Like Victoria said, it's difficult to talk about without giving too much away. It is beautifully written, but beautiful writing can only make up for so much.

    "The Orginorg Way" also seemed to take a dim view of women. I'm not a great fan of Sharkey and this did nothing to improve my attitude.

    Fafhrd and the Mouser righted the ship somewhat. A fine enough tale of the daring duo, though somewhat predictable and, again, over long. Some incidents (in both halves) felt like padding. This would probably have been better cut down to make a long novella for one issue.

    I've also not been a big fan of Bunch. I don't hate his work as so many readers seem to, nor do I think he's all that entertaining. "Whoosh" is perhaps one of the better stories I've seen from him, but that's not that high a hurdle.

    Back in November, I expressed some concern that Bradford would carry on with the rest of Gulliver's travels. Alas, he has. There's nothing here, and Swift is probably spinning in his grave. Are we facing two more of these things? Maybe a vigorous letter writing campaign can dissuade Miss Goldsmith from finishing the set. (Probably not, or she'd have stopped running Bunch years ago.)

    The final story seems to take another negative view of women. Or maybe, as Victoria suggests, the author just came up with a scary idea and went where it took him. Not a bad story. It would have fit in quite well in EC Comics back in the days before the Comics Code.

    So maybe not as misogynistic as I remembered it being, but there did seem to be a thread. And definite room for improvement, though some of my dissatisfaction is the result of a couple of authors I don't much care for. All in all, this is just turning out to be a poor month for science fiction overall. I predict that Galaxy will be the best issue of the month, but with a fairly mediocre score.

  2. I have to admit I quite like The Beatles. Nice music, nice songs, lots of potential. Makes me sad that I missed them when they played in Hamburg's Star Club a few years ago, before they were superstars.

    As for this month's Fantastic, Philip K. Dick is turning into a fine satirist. The Disch/Thorpe was a neat little horror story and might make a fine episode of Twilight Zone one day. David R. Bunch is a strange, but definitely interesting writer. And Fafhrd and Gray Mouser are always fun to hang out with, even if The Lords of Quarmall was weaker than the duo's usual adventures and overly long. But then, it's apparently a very early tale that Leiber rewrote, which might account for the issues.

    I didn't care for the Bradford, Sharkey and Thomas

    1. I got both the Beatles new albums, "Introducing" and "Meet" — I understand they are the second and first albums (respectively) released in England, with "Meet" missing Love Me Do and P.S. I Love You (which is okay — I have them on 45).

      They're both good, but "Introducing" is better, and Don't Bother Me (first song, second side) has a new sound I've never heard before.  Exciting stuff!

      1. " Introducing" is mostly taken from their debut U. K. album, "Please Please Me". "Meet" have mostly the second U. K. album, "With the Beatles", with the only dupe between the two albums is "I Saw Her Standing There" (Althrough the Vee-Jay one cut out the "1-2-3" bit).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *