[Oct. 15, 1961] Top of the Third (The Twilight Zone, Season 3)


by Gideon Marcus

and


by Lorelei Marcus

Two years ago, CBS aired the first episode of a new television anthology, one destined for the history books.  It was called The Twilight Zone, and it featured science fiction and fantasy themed stories in a most sophisticated fashion.  Twilight Zone garnered its creator, Rod Serling, a much deserved Emmy, and if Serling be remembered for nothing else, it’s certain he will leave a lasting legacy.

The new season began last month, and though I had high hopes, Serling’s creation is starting to feel a little tired.  Word through the grapevine is he’s a bit storied out, and the episodes that used to flow like water from his pen come a lot more sluggishly.  That said, a half hour of Twilight Zone is still better than most hours of other television — and two hours have already been aired this year.  Let’s take a look, shall we?  (Synopsis first, then my commentary followed by the Young Traveler’s)

First up is Two, and it’s easily my favorite of the new crop.  This may well be attributable to it having been written by someone other than Serling – in this case, writer/director Montgomery Pittman.  Two features an abandoned urban setting some years after the start of World War Three.  A ragged young invader (Elizabeth Montgomery) in a threadbare uniform is scavenging for scraps when she runs across a similarly bedraggled native soldier (Charles Bronson).  Though the latter would be quite happy to forget the horrors of war, the Russian woman continues the conflict, repeatedly attacking the American.  Ultimately, through kindness and appeal to reason, Bronson convinces Montgomery to give up the fight, her gun, her uniform, and the two head off into the sunset as friends. 

There is little dialogue in this episode and no twist.  It’s just a little post-apocalyptic meet cute.  What makes Two work is the sublime cinematography, the deft acting.  Bronson has already proven to be a charismatic leading man (q.v. Master of the Air), and Montgomery delivered her virtually wordless role convincingly.  Four stars.

Over the past couple of weeks, me and my father have been watching the first few episodes of the new season!  The first episode was fairly standard.  It was, once again, about life after a nuclear dust-up.  There were only two characters, a male and female soldier from opposite sides of the war.  The episode was basically just them interacting, and almost no words were spoken.  It was exactly what it was trying to be, and I don’t really have much else to say about it.  You may watch it if you like, but honestly, I would recommend skipping this episode.  Two stars.

Serling-penned The Arrival begins compellingly enough: a DC-3 lands at a busy airport with not a single soul or piece of luggage on board.  Grant Sheckly, an FAA investigator, is brought in to crack the case.  A little past halfway, realizing that none of the pieces are adding up to a coherent whole, Sheckly concludes that the plane is an illusion, the result of some kind of hypnosis.  In a tense scene, Sheckly places his hand in the path of the plane’s spinning propeller, and the aircraft disappears…along with the rest of the airport crew in the hangar with him! 

Sadly, this is the peak of the episode.  It turns out that the DC-3 is not some kind of ghost ship, nor is there some sinister purpose behind the apparition.  Rather, the plane is a personal demon of Sheckly’s; 17 years ago, the plane had disappeared without a trace, and Sheckly’s inability to solve the case has haunted him ever since.  It’s entirely too prosaic an explanation for The Twilight Zone, quite possibly the least satisfying resolution to what started as a most promising episode.  Two stars.

The second episode was interesting, at least until the end.  It was about a ghost plane with no one on it, and the man who was trying to figure out how it landed by itself.  His eventual conclusion was that the plane simply didn’t exist, and that turned out to be true.  In the end, the man was just crazy, end of story.  In my opinion there were a lot of stupid moments that could’ve easily been avoided that really damaged the story.  It was an interesting concept, but not very well carried out.  Despite the bad ending, I would recommend watching this one, as there were some interesting parts.  Two and a half stars.

The lackluster run continues through The Shelter, another Serling story.  A convivial birthday party for a neighborhood doctor is broken up by a bulletin from CONELRAD: unidentified flying objects, believed to be missiles, have been detected, and there is but a matter of minutes to reach safety.  The forward-thinking sawbones had built a shelter in his basement, and he quickly repairs there with his family.  Then the doctor’s friends arrive, each pleading to be let in, but the doctor refuses.  Whipped into a panicked frenzy, the neighbors bickeringly debate breaking into the shelter, then fight amongst themselves for the privilege of displacing the doctor’s family.  Racial slurs are cast against the one Jewish neighbor.  Just as the friends batter down the door to the shelter, CONELRAD announces that the UFOs were harmless space debris.  The neighbors, shamefaced, attempt to apologize to the doctor, but it is clear that the trappings of civilization cling loosely to them – and to the physician, as well, who refused to share his refuge. 

It’s not horrible, but this message was done more satisfyingly (and in a less over-the-top fashion) in the first season episode, The Monsters are due on Maple Street.  Two stars.

Episode three was fairly straight-forward.  It re-explored a common Twilight Zone topic of testing human nature under immense stress and danger.  I didn’t enjoy it very much, simply because people going crazy and yelling at eachother is not my cup of tea.  However, it is still an interesting episode and I recommend you watch it.  Three stars.

Last up for now is yet another Serling episode, the Civil War piece, The Passerby.  In the wake of Appomattox, a train of bedraggled soldiers trudges past a burned out home toward a final destination.  The inhabitant of the house is a fever-ridden widow whose husband died at Gettysburg.  She is joined by a maimed Confederate sergeant, who keeps her company as they are visited by several spectral forms in uniform.  One is the husband of one of the widow’s friends, a man the widow believed had been killed.  Then a Union lieutenant whose death the sergeant personally witnessed arrives, asking for water. 

The next morning, the sergeant confesses to a deep desire to continue down the road.  As the widow pleads for him not to leave, she hears the rich baritone of her husband.  He arrives, embracing her, and it is clear now that he, the sergeant, and even the widow are all ghosts of the war dead.  Last up the road is Honest Abe, himself, the last casualty of the “Great Unpleasantness.”

The first half is a talky muddle, the widow giving an overwrought performance of the kind I might expect in a high school play.  Yet, even though it was clear where the story was going (and I have, in fact made fun of shows employing this exact gimmick), I found its resolution somewhat moving.  It’s nicely scored, too.  It deserves two stars, but I’ll give it three anyway.

Last week’s episode was probably my favorite.  It was about a civil war fighter on the long road home who stops, seeking hospitality from a nice young woman.  I won’t spoil too much (though it looks like my dad may have), but despite the predictable ending, I still enjoyed the episode.  The acting was good, the sets, though simple, were attractive, and just overall it had a moody feel.  Of course, I highly recommend you watch this one on your own.  Three and a half stars.

So ends the first batch of the third season.  A mediocre batch, to be sure, though I have to remember that Season Two started badly, too. 

Next week, Galactic Journey will return to the written word.  It’s a little book called The Planet Strappers, and I think you’ll enjoy it (the review, if not the book).  In the meantime, as you know, I went to a small convention in Seattle last week.  While there, I met a lovely young lady who has since become a fan of this column.  She is a fashion model as well as the owner of a clothing store, and she sent me a photo to be included in the column as a kind of advertisement.  Please meet Sarah, the Journey’s latest Fellow Traveler.

10 thoughts on “[Oct. 15, 1961] Top of the Third (The Twilight Zone, Season 3)”

  1. Thank you both for these television reviews. The first episode sounds more like a showpiece for actors to display, and I’m glad you at least had good actors.  Inventing a better end for The Arrival sounds a fun game. And The Passer By does come across as a plus (especially for us history buffs).

      1. One you’ll do better than…How about it being a child’s toy from the far future, or from some giants in another dimension?

  2. “Two” is definitely the best of these episodes, the other three already starting to fade from memory.

    Sarah looks quite elegant and stylish in her Little Black Dress.  She reminds me of Audrey Hepburn in the current film “Breakfast at Tiffany’s.”

  3. “Two” is definitely the best of these. And I’m glad this one didn’t have a twist, because the only twist I could think of, and one I was sure they were going for, would be for Bronson’s character to introduce himself as Adam and Montgomery’s character to say her name is Eve. Instead we wind up with a nicely acted character study on the aftermath of war. I can understand the Junior Traveler not really liking it. She may (though she won’t like to hear it) be just a little too junior. If she catches a rerun in a few years, I bet she’ll like it more.

    The less said about “The Arrival”, the better. They did this one better last year with “King Nine Will Not Return”.

    We’ve certainly seen “The Shelter” before. Not just here, but it really isn’t all that different from Lifeboat or even The Ox-Bow Incident.

    “The Passersby” was all right.  Nothing special and I think it benefited from follow two fairly weak episodes.

    All in all, I think the lesson is that we need more stories from other writers. It’s all right if Serling does the script, but more ideas from other sources helps. He isn’t a terrible writer, but he does have a lot on his plate. On top of his on-screen appearances, he’s also the producer, and that’s a lot of work. Churning out 20-30 creative scripts in addition is probably asking too much.

  4. I wasn’t terribly impressed with any of these episodes.

    Your description of “Two” as a post-apocalyptic meet-cute is dead on; in my opinion that’s not enough to carry a story by itself (although it can work as a B-plot), and putting science-fiction trappings on it doesn’t help with that.  Also, why is it always the woman who has to give up her ideals and her identity just so that the man can have a sex partner?

    The only way “The Arrival” could have been worse would be if it had turned out to be a dream rather than a hallucination.

    “The Shelter” is a trope that’s been done to death, and lacks any distinction that would make it stand out from the other thousand or so stories built on the same premise.

    “The Passer-by” happened to hit one of my personal dislikes — the Civil War has been over for a hundred years, and I don’t understand why so many people can’t just let it go! But even without that, the “everyone in the story turns out to be a ghost” trope is another one that’s been done to death and requires something really unusual to make it interesting — which this version lacks.

  5. I caught a few episodes last season, but frankly, I’ve not bothered with the current season.  The show isn’t really SF or horror; all I’ve seen is some kind of nihilistic preachiness that usually leaves me feeling vaguely depressed.

    We’re watching having fun watching The Flintstones, though.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.