[January 26, 1965] Down the Rabbit Hole…Again (February 1965 IF)


by Gideon Marcus

TV Triplets

Back when the Young Traveler and I were watching The Twilight Zone, we accidentally picked the wrong time to turn on the set and ended up getting introduced to Mr. Ed, Supercar, and The Andy Griffith Show, in that order.  It made for an amusing night, and we learned a lot about the prime-time schedule for that season.

Recently, we once again fell down the rabbit hole, though not quite by accident. 

It all started with an amazing new import form England.  You may have seen the American rebroadcast of Danger Man back in the summer of '61.  It was a smart spy show starring NATO agent, John Drake, played by Patrick McGoohan.  Well, he's back, and this time his episodes are a full hour rather than just half.  It's gripping stuff, albeit a bit heavier and more cynical than the first run.  Realistic, idealistic, and respectful of women, it's a delightful contrast to the buffoonish Bond franchise.

So gripping was the show that we ended up somehow unable to change the channel when Password came on.  This game show is sort of a verbal version of Charades where a contestant tries to get their partner to say a word using single-word clues.  Play goes back and forth until one team gets it right.

It's kind of a dumb show for the viewer because we already know the answer.  On the other hand, the contestants always include celebrities, and it's fun to watch them struggle through the rounds.


Gene Kelly looked like he wanted to kill his partner.  The whole time!


Juliet Prowse, on the other hand, was adorable and funny.

After half an hour of that, we had summoned enough energy to reach toward the television remote…until we heard the bugle strains heralding the arrival of Rocky and Bullwinkle (and friends).  It had been my understanding that the show had completed its five year run, but it has apparently gone into reruns without missing a beat.  Since we had missed the first couple of years, well, we couldn't turn off the television now!

The only thing that saved us was the subsequent airing of Bonanza, a show I am only too happy to turn off.  Who knows how long we'd have cruised The Vast Wasteland otherwise.  Of course, now we're stuck watching all three shows every week (homework permitting).

Print Analog

Science fiction magazines are kind of like blocks of TV shows.  They happen regularly, their quality is somewhat reliable, but their content varies with each new issue.  This month's Worlds of IF Science Fiction defined the phrase "much of a muchness".  Each (for the most part) was acceptable, even enjoyable, but either they were flawed jewels, or they simply never went beyond workmanlike.  Read on, and you'll see what I mean:


This rather goofy cover courtesy of McKenna, illustrating Small One

The Replicators, by A. E. van Vogt

Steve Maitlin is an ornery SOB, a Marine veteran of Korea who knows the world is all SNAFU, especially the moronic generals who run the show.  Not only does this attitude make life miserable for those around him, but it also brings the Earth to the brink of interstellar war.  It turns out that the alien BEM Maitlin shoots one day on the road to work is just one of an infinite number of bodies for an IT, and the replacement body ends up with Maitlin's cussedness as part of its basic personality.

Said IT also has the ability to replicate any weapon the humans throw against it, but magnified.  Shoot at it?  It builds a big-size rifle.  Bomb it?  It comes back with an extra-jumbo jet and a bigger nuke.  In the end, Maitlin is the only one who can stop the thing, which makes karmic sense.  But can the vet change his nature in time to meet minds with the alien?


by Gray Morrow

This story doesn't make a lot of sense, but Van Vogt is good at keeping you engaged with pulpish momentum.  Three stars.

Reporter at Large, by Ron Goulart

In a future where mob bosses have replaced politicians (or perhaps the politicians have just more nakedly advertised their criminal nature!) power is entrenched and hereditary.  Only an honest journalist can bring about a revolution, but when any person has his price, only an android editor's got the scruples to speak truth to power.

Ron Goulart writes good, funny stories.  Unfortunately, while I see that he tried, he failed at accomplishing either this time out.  Two stars, and the worst piece of the mag.

Small One, by E. Clayton McCarty

A young alien has exiled himself as part of its first stage of five on the journey toward maturity.  Its isolation is disturbed when a tiny bipedal creature lands in a spaceship nearby and finds itself trapped in a cave.  The child-being establishes telepathic contact with the intruder (obviously a human) and an eventual rapport is established.  But everything falls apart when the Terran's rapacious teammates land and fall into conflict with the alien's infinitely more powerful family…


by Jack Gaughan

I am a sucker for first contact stories, especially when told from the alien viewpoint.  This one is good, but it suffers from a certain lack of subtlety, a kind of hamfisted presentation of the kind I normally see from new writers.  That makes sense; this is his (her?) first story.

Three stars, and my favorite piece of the magazine.

Blind Alley, by Basil Wells

A year after settling the planet of Croft, the human colonists and their livestock all become afflicted with blindness.  Against the odds, they survive, shaping their lives around the change.  But can their society take the shock when a new arrival, generations later, brings back the promise of sight?

Blind Alley treads much of the same ground as Daniel Galouye's excellent Dark Universe from a few years back.  The question is worth asking: when is a "disability" simply a different way to be able?  That said, Wells is not as skilled as Galouye, and the story merits three stars as a result.

Gree's Commandos, by C. C. MacApp


by Nodel

On a thick-atmosphered planet, Colonel Steve Duke assists a race of Stone Age flying elephants against the interstellar aggressors, the Gree, and their mercentary cohorts.  It's a straight adventure piece with virtually no development, either of the characters or the larger setting.  Somewhat similar to Keith Laumer's latest novel (The Hounds of Hell, also appearing in IF), it doesn't do anything to make you care.  Sufficiently developed, it could have been good.

Two stars.

Zombie, by J. L. Frye

Here is the second story by a brand new author…and it shows.  In the future, it becomes possible to transplant a personality in the short term to a physically perfect body.  Said transfers are used almost exclusively for espionage and sabotage — it's not much fun living in a shell of a form that can't really feel or enjoy anything other than the satisfaction of a job well done.  Indeed, the only people willing to endure the hell of personality transfer (back and forth) are the profoundly crippled.

This story of a particularly hairy mission has its moments of poignance, but again, Frye is not quite up to the challenge of a difficult topic.  Plus, he needs more adjectives in his quiver; I count seven times he used "beautiful" to describe the sole female character.  Even Homer varied between calling Athena "grey-eyed" and "owl-eyed".

Three stars.

Starchild (Part 2 of 3), by Frederik Pohl and Jack Williamson

Last up is the second installment of three (that number again!) in this serialized sequel to The Reefs of Space.  It's a short one, barely long enough to cover the harsh interrogation of Bowsie Gann.  Gann was the loyal spy servant of The Plan, returned to Earth at the same time the star-reef-dwelling Starchild began to turn off the local suns to scare Earth's machine-run government.


by Nodel

It's a most unpleasant set of pages, with lots of torture and cruelty (something Fred Pohl does effectively; viz. A Plague of Pythons).  That said, Pohl and Williamson can write, and I am looking forward to seeing how it all wraps up.

Three stars.

Stay Tuned

Like much of the Idiot Box's offerings, IF continues to deliver stuff that's just good enough to keep my subscription current.  I'd like editor Fred Pohl to tip the magazine in one direction or another so I can either stop buying it or enjoy it more…

Until then, I guess my knob stays tuned to this channel!



[If you have a membership to this year's Worldcon (in New Zealand) or did last year (Dublin), we would very much appreciate your nomination for Best Fanzine! We work for egoboo…]




6 thoughts on “[January 26, 1965] Down the Rabbit Hole…Again (February 1965 IF)”

  1. I don't think this is enough to get me to pickup this month's IF so won't comment on the stories but I am glad you are both continuing to enjoy Danger Man. It was a wonderful surprise to have it turn up again on ATV and liking it a lot. McGoohan is such a fine actor.

  2. Basil Wells a freshman author?  Er, no–he's been at it, on and off, for nearly 25 years, starting with the September 1940 SUPER SCIENCE STORIES ("Rebirth of Man").  But he is easy to overlook.  Your comments may be about the highest praise he has ever received (or merited).

    1. Whoops!  From the various lists I'm able to get my hands on, it looks like he's been out of action for many years, and during the '50s, he stuck mostly to mags I wasn't reading.  Thank you for the clarification!

  3. "Danger Man" is quite a fine series.  Much more serious and intense than the over-the-top adventures of playboy James Bond.

    Not a fan of "Password."  Give me "Jeopardy" instead.  (Of course, that's just during the daytime.  Pity the poor person who has to pull all those pieces of cardboard to reveal the answers.)

    Rocky and Bullwinkle, despite crude animation, is quite sophisticated humor.  Natasha Fatale is another of my role models.

    Anyway, on to the important stuff.

    "The Replicators" was a lot more readable that the usual Van Vogt.  It wasn't a comedy, but I got the impression that the author had his tongue in his cheek while writing the early part of the story, which seemed like a wry version of a "sci-fi" monster movie from the last decade.  I'm not sure I believe the "king Marine" concept, but as a whole the story wasn't bad.

    "Reporter at Large" seemed like the author just going through the motions, with his usual stuff.  A bit of satire of the newspaper games was OK.  The plot wasn't much.

    "Small One" was so-so.  It went on too long for a fairly simple concept.

    I found it odd that the main character in "Blind Alley" had any concept at all of seeing, and that he didn't freak out the way his girlfriend did when getting his artificial vision.  Other than that, it was another mediocre work.

    "Gree's Commandos" was just an action/adventure/war/spy yarn, with some alien exotica.  The ending, with the cavalry doming to the rescue, sure came out of nowhere.

    "Zombie" suffers from a long patch of dry exposition.  There's some emotional power, but much of the plot is just a pulp crime story.

    So, as you've said, a fair-to-middling issue, nothing really standing out.  If I had to pick a favorite, it would be the Van Vogt, which surprises the heck out of me.

  4. Much like a lot of stuff on television, most of what's in this issue is mildly entertaining and completely forgettable.

    The van Vogt didn't make a whole lot of sense, though it was interesting. Alas, I've reached a point with him where I keep wondering if he's spouting Dianetics at us. Fortunately, I don't know enough about Hubbard's nonsense to be able to tell, but that gnawing concern is always there.

    I enjoyed the Goulart, possibly enough to give it a very low three. He didn't quite achieve what he set out to do, true, but he came close enough.

    "Small One" was simply too long. The reveal of the alien as a human came far too late. It was obvious from fairly early on (though some of that might have been due to the illustrations really giving away the game). I repeatedly found myself getting bored and wanting the author to get on with it already.

    "Blind Alley" is probably the most forgettable of the stories. I've certainly forgotten everything about it since reading it a couple of weeks ago. Always a bad sign.

    "Gree's Commandos" was an average adventure story. It's probably a little more palatable if you remember "The Slaves of Gree" from last summer. A little. At least Steve Duke gets to be Steve Duke for the whole story this time.

    "Starchild" continues to be better than "Reefs of Space" but I can't say I'm really enjoying it. We'll see how it wraps up next month.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *