[December 26, 1966] Harvesting the Starfields (1966's Galactic Stars!)


by Gideon Marcus

There are many outlets that cover new releases in science fiction and fantasy.  But to my knowledge, only one attempts to review every English language publication in the world (not to mention stuff published beyond the U.S. and U.K.!) We are proud of the coverage we provide.

And this is the time of year when the bounty is tallied.  From all the books, magazines, comic strips, movies, tv shows, we separate the wheat from the chaff, and then sift again until only the very best is left.

These, then, are the Galactic Stars for 1966!

We have tried to keep the winners to a manageable three winners, but as you'll see, the honorable mentions rather got away from themselves.  That's because there was simply more fiction produced this year, what with the three British mags and all.  This is a fine problem to have, too much good stuff.

Results are in order of voting for the winners, alphabetical order by author for the honorable mentions.

——
Best Poetry
——

Poetry is always an underrepresented field within SF.  Rather than declare a winner in this category, we simply present the four pieces we liked the most this year.

The Gods, by L. Sprague de Camp

Memo to Secretary, by Pat de Graw

The Last Song Sung in Lorien, by Robert Foster

The Case, by Peter Redgrove

——
Best Vignettes (1-8 pages)
——

Day Million, by Frederik Pohl

Some writers take no chances when predicting the future.  Pohl is not among them…

Love Is an Imaginary Number, by Roger Zelazny

A modern spin on the Prometheus legend.

Breakaway House, by Ron Goulart

A Max Kearney, occult detective, story.  Genuinely funny.

Honorable Mention:

The Plot Sickens, by Brian W. Aldiss

You and Me and the Continuum, by J. G. Ballard

The Plot is the Thing, by Robert Bloch

But Soft, What Light … , by Carol Emshwiller

Mute Milton, by Harry Harrison

Mr. Wilde's Second Chance, by Joanna Russ

We had more vignettes to choose from this year, with the result that more made the list.  Their content ranged from frivolous fantasy to deadly serious social commentary.  It's always impressive when an author can say a lot with a little.

——
Best Short Stories (9-19 pages)
——

The Squirrel Cage, by Thomas M. Disch

Why is the man trapped in a room with only a typewriter and the newspaper for company?


Honorable Mention

No other story got more than one vote by a Journeyer, though virtually all got at least four stars.  So, instead of providing summaries or attempting ranks, the following will be listed by recommender.

By John Boston:

When I Was Miss Dow, by Sonya Dorman

At the Core, by Larry Niven

The Roaches, by Thomas M. Disch

By Cora Bulhert:

The Bells of Shoredan, by Roger Zelazny

High Treason, by Poul Anderson

Splice of Life, by Sonya Dorman

By David Levinson:

The Face of the Deep, by Fred Saberhagen

Halfway House, by Robert Silverberg

By Gideon Marcus:

Come Lady Death , by Peter S. Beagle

A Code for Sam, by Lester del Rey

Contact Man, by Harry Harrison

By Kris Vyas-Myall:

The Great Clock , by Langdon Jones

The Loolies Are Here, short story by Allison Rice

By Victoria Silverwolf:

Stars, Won't You Hide Me?, by Ben Bova

Light of Other Days, by Bob Shaw

The Worlds That Were, by Keith Roberts

——
Best Novelettes (20-40 pages)
——

Riverworld, by Philip José Farmer

All of humanity is ressurrected on the banks of the world-river.  Including Tom Mix and a certain carpenter from Nazareth…

For a Breath I Tarry, by Roger Zelazny

Two computer brains endeavor to know long-dead humanity.  Beautiful.  Powerful.


A Two-Timer, by David I. Masson

A 17th Century scholar sojourns for a time in Our Modern Times.  Delightful.

Angels Unawares, by Zenna Henderson

An early tale of The People.  Kin can be adopted as well as born.


Honorable Mention

An Ornament to His Profession, by Charles L. Harness

Pavane: Lords & Ladies, by Keith Roberts

The Disinherited, by Poul Anderson

The Keys to December, by Roger Zelazny

Defence Mechanism, by Vincent King

Wings of a Bat, by Paul Ash (Pauline Ashwell)

The Eyes of the Blind King, by Brian W. Aldiss

Be Merry, by Algis Budrys

We Can Remember It for You Wholesale, by Philip K. Dick

The Phoenix and the Mirror, by Avram Davidson

——
Best Novella (40+ pages)
——

Behold the Man, by Michael Moorcock

If Jesus did not exist, it would be necessary for a time traveler to go back and invent him…

The Manor of Roses, by Thomas Burnett Swann

A lordlet and his peasant blood brother encounter Mandrakes on the way to the Crusades.


The Last Castle , by Jack Vance

All the bastions of humanity have fallen to the aliens save one.  Vance at his most lyrical.

Pavane: Corfe Gate, by Keith Roberts

In an England that remained Catholic, Lady Eleanor leads a rebellion at Corfe Gate.  The capstone of the Pavane saga.

Honorable Mention

The Suicide Express, by Philip José Farmer (another Riverworld tale)

Synth, by Keith Roberts (Is an android a person?)

Prisoners of the Sky, by C.C. McApp (saving the plateau world of Durrent from alien invaders)

Good novellas are usually few and far between.  We raised a bumper crop this year!

——
Best Novel/Serial
——

Babel-17, by Samuel R. Delany

Hands down the winner.  Brilliant linguist Rydra Wong must decipher the secret of the alien's language before more traitors bring down humanity from within.  There's never been anything quite like this progressive masterpiece (though Purdom's I Want the Stars has hints of it).


Flowers for Algernon, by Daniel Keyes

Charlie Gordon is a moron…until he's a genius.  What next?  An expansion of the brilliant novelette, garnering the Galactic Star in both incarnations.

The Moon Is a Harsh Mistress, by Robert A. Heinlein

The Moon is a revolting place.  Featuring the neatest synthetic character ever portrayed!

October the First is too Late, by Fred Hoyle

The world is fractured into a myriad of time zones, but why?

Sibyl Sue Blue, by Rosel George Brown

She's tiny, she's tough, and Sergeant Blue is going to crack the benzale murder case, even if she has to go to the stars to do it.

Make Room! Make Room!, by Harry Harrison

There is a critical density for humanity; Harrison's exploration of the Malthusian world is profoundly disturbing.

Honorable Mention

Sword of Lankor, by Howard Cory

Now Wait for Last Year, by Philip K. Dick

Earthworks, by Brian W. Aldiss

The Crystal World, by J.G. Ballard

Too Many Magicians, by Randall Garrett

The New Wave is definitely upon us, with only the Heinlein truly "conventional" SF (but the best he's turned in yet!) I am pleased that women are represented in each of these categories, though still dismayed at the relative dearth of them.  This was a very lean year for woman-penned science fiction.

If there be a Hugo category for "Best Publisher" next year, we'll be surprised if Ace or Doubleday aren't among the nominees——they had, by far, the most outstanding books in 1966.

——
Best Science Fact
——

For Your Information: The Sound of the Meteors, by Willy Ley


Drifting Continents, by Robert S. Dietz

H. P. Lovecraft: The House and the Shadows, by J. Vernon Shea

BB or Not BB, That Is the Question, by Isaac Asimov

Dimensions in Heinlein, by Alexei Panshin

The Economics of SF, by John Brunner

Dimensions, Anyone?, by John D. Clark, Ph.D.

Asimov no longer dominates the field, in part because he's starting to struggle for material, and also because we're doing a better job of keeping up with the 'zines.  These are all great articles, though.  Accessible and interesting.

——
Best Magazine/Collection
——

Orbit: 3.36 stars, 3 Star nominees

Science Fantasy/Impulse: 3.23 stars, 6 Star nominees

New Worlds: 3.21 stars, 7 Star nominees

Fantastic: 3.20 stars, 2 Star nominees

New Writings: 3.13 stars, 1 Star nominee

F&SF: 3.099 stars, 10 Star nominees

Galaxy: 3.097 stars, 3 Star nominees

Alien Worlds: 3 stars, 1 Star nominee

IF: 2.91 stars, 7 Star nominees

Analog: 2.89 stars, 5 Star nominees

Worlds of Tomorrow: 2.66 stars, 3 Star nominees

Amazing: 2.37 stars, 1 Star nominee

This is always an apples and oranges category since collections are published much more rarely than magazines, some magazines are monthly while others are bi-monthly (or even quarterly), and both Fantastic and Amazing are composed mostly of reprints.  Nevertheless, the two UK mags definitely stood out this year, with New Worlds slightly more experimental, and thus variable, than Science FantasyGalaxy is the more reliable, but also more stolid sister of IFWorlds of Tomorrow does not seem long for this world…

——
Best Artist
——

John Schoenherr

Frank Frazetta

Kelly Freas

Gray Morrow

George Zeil

——
Best Dramatic Presentation
——

The War Game

A chilling documentary-style exploration of an atomic blast on England.
ㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤㅤ

Doctor Who: The War Machines

Seconds

Star Trek: "The Menagerie"

Raumpatrouille Orion: "The Space Trap"

Out of the Unknown: "The Midas Plague"

Flight of the Phoenix (unreviewed, but boy is it good!)

——
Best Comic Book
——

Spiderman

X-Men


Asterix in Britain

Blazing Combat

Doom Patrol

Fantastic Four

The Rise and Fall of the Trigan Empire

Marvel Comics is now in a dominating position, putting out some of the most dynamic, popular mags.  National (DC) is barely keeping a toehold in with their FF-derived Doom Patrol.  Beyond the Big Two, Blazing Combat, by Warren Publications, offers a much more nuanced, even anti-war alternative to Sgt. Rock and Sgt. Fury.  France is represented with the Gaul-era Asterix in Britain, while Britain's Trigan Empire, appearing in Ranger and Look and Learn (sequentially) gets the Star for that nation.

Sadly, I've not been back to Japan since '64, which means I'm missing out on loads of terrific manga.  Well, maybe next year…

——
Best Fanzine
——

Riverside Quarterly

Yandro

Amra

Australian Science Fiction Review

Lighthouse (annual pros' fanzine)

Nikeas

Ratatosk (news)

Science Fiction Times (news)

Tolkien Journal

Zenith

Riverside Quarterly, with its scholarly pieces, and Juanita Coulson's Yandro, one of the most balanced of 'zines, continue to impress.  This will probably be the last year SFT makes it on the ballot given its reduced schedule.  But with the recent republishing of LoTR, I expect Tolkien Journal to be with us a long time.


And so, another year's crop is harvested.  I think, on the main, 1966 yielded superior fruit than '65.  Women continue to be underrepresented, but also consistently produce some of the best material.  Imagine what the field would be like with equal participation!

One big change is that science fiction is no longer entirely the province of the written word.  With the arrival of Star Trek, Space Patrol Orion, and more SF themed shows in general, not to mention the flourishing of comic books, SF is diversifying, infiltrating the mainstream.  What long-term effects this has remain to be seen: will science fiction dilute itself into pap?  Or will it explode as the audience grows?

Stay tuned next year!  Until then, keep watching the Stars…





15 thoughts on “[December 26, 1966] Harvesting the Starfields (1966's Galactic Stars!)”

  1. Lovely! Very pleasantly pleased to see the British magazines doing so well, although there was some very good stuff there, admittedly. I think that there are stories I've read this year that I will remember for a long time, and hope others think the same too.

  2. I look at IF coming 9th out of 12 and despair a little bit. Yet it also managed to tie with New Worlds for second in number of nominees. That seems to have been the pattern ever since I took over the reviewing duties. When IF is good, it's very, very good, but otherwise forgettable at best and hold your nose when it fails to achieve even that modest height.

    But I've also had the feeling that the last few months of '66 and the start of '67 showed a marked increase in overall quality. (That or I've become so desensitized to the material, I'm starting to rate the mediocre stuff higher than it deserves.) However it may be, it gives me some reason to hope.

  3. In the fanzine section did you meanJohn Bangsund’s “Australian Science Fiction Review” rather than “Quarterly”? I don’t recognise the ASFQ title.

  4. Like If, Fantasy and Science Fiction has a lot of nominees but only a middle-of-the-road rating.  I suppose that could partly be due to the fact that they publish a lot of short pieces; more stories per issue.  Add to that the fact that they're monthly, and they probably publish a much larger number of works of fiction than any other magazine in the field.

    I wonder what the "number of nominees" to "number of stories" ratio would be for all the publications.

    1. I was curious so I tried to do this quickly.

      First off, all those publications with single figures of eligible nominees had over 20% of them as star nominees:
      Fantastic: 33%
      Orbit: 33%
      Alien Worlds: 25%
      Amazing: 20%

      Among those with a higher number of eligible works:
      F&SF: 9.4%
      If: 9.0%
      NW: 8.3%
      SF\Imp: 8.3%
      WOT: 7.9%
      Analog: 7.5%
      Galaxy: 6.7%
      New Writings: 5.3%

      With New Writings I don't think that is necessarily a sign that it has been the most unremarkable publicaton this year but that it doesn't tend to be as widely read as the magazines

  5. 1966 was a great year for science fiction novels, and it was a pleasure reading so many of them. I agree that "Babel-17" was the clear standout, a mind-expanding novel about the connections between language and thought that was endlessly intriguing. I was frightened by "Make Room! Make Room!" I think those advocating for ZPG are a bit fanatical, but this book makes a powerful case for the problems mankind will face if it doesn't confront its overpopulation problems.

    I also thought Ursula LeGuin's "Planet of Exile" merited mention, as I found it quite beautiful written and a nice counterpoint to "Lord of the Rings."

    In comics, I'm absolutely shocked the staff chose X-Men as a notable comic of 1966 when the series has been at its most uninspired so far (not a high bar since this is clearly Marvel's worst title), with the bland Werner Roth art and absurdly wordy Roy Thomas stories making it a must-miss.

    Fantastic Four, on the other hand, just finished an incredible year, starting with the incredible conclusion of the Galactus saga, the introduction of the Black Panther (who has tremendous potential), and an incredible Doctor Doom story. Jack Kirby is indeed the king!

    1. And 'This Man, This Monster' in FF #51! But yes — the FF was indeed 'The World's Greatest Comic Magazine' .  Truth in advertising for once.

    2. I have been enjoying what I have seen so far of The Fantastic Four, however, in the UK our reprints have only got as far as Namor and Dr. Doom stealing the Baxter Building into space, so it will be a while before we catch up I think!

  6. Coming out of the woodwork to thank the whole Galactic crew for your coverage! A great crop of novels—I haven't read "Deathworld" yet, but I agree on the sheer brilliance of "Babel-17" (and as someone who's never liked Heinlein, I even found "Harsh Mistress" pretty cool). This was the year I finally went back & read all of Henderson's People stories, which I have you folks to thank. And I agree with the other readers that Fantastic Four is head-and-orange-rocky-shoulders above The X-Men. I caught "The War Game" at the NYC Film Festival, and agree it's even better than "Seconds."

    As for Star Trek, my favorites have been "The Corbomite Maneuver" and last week's "Balance of Terror." And it's thrilling that Europe has Doctor Who and Raumpatrouille Orion. It seems unlikely they'll ever be screened in the US, but with ABC broadcasting the Avengers (the English TV program, not the American Marvel comic), we can hope!

  7. Thank you, Aaron.

    I don't normally get chance to talk much about British television, but I am pleased The Avengers have been mentioned – I love it! Doctor Who is usually good, although I must admit Jess's brilliant reviews here make me see them in a new light!

    And my new latest favourite, though it really shouldn't be because it is aimed at children and involves puppets, is the ITV series Thunderbirds, which makes me think like a child again (in a positive way!)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *